Twilight begins slowly. Stephanie Meyer builds her characters nicely and describes the setting vividly. My only problem was– her grammar– she seems to write sentances– that have many odd pauses. I almost considered putting the book down because it began to bother me. Does she not know how to use commas? Eventually I grew used to the weird pauses her narration took as I got more into the story.
I began to bond with Isabella, the main character, after a period of time. Although the novel and the weird relationship she formed with the vampire, Edward, seemed to come straight out of some Mary Sue fanfiction. It wasn’t the construction of the characters, it was the way they reacted to one another. Isabella and Edward fell in head over heels passionate love. They confessed to each other all the time. By the eighteenth time, I began to get bored with the storyline. I will say that Isabella was a very likable character. I truly identified with her. She had all of my tastes in literature and men.
The story itself is sweet. It reminds me of a slightly twisted Sarah Dressen novel. If you haven’t read Dressen, she’s good for one thing: making you wish you had a boyfriend. Though it read like a drawn out, tawdry day dream in many parts. The struggle seemed to center Isabella and her own inability to “see how wonderful she was”. Even though she was told by like, a billion vampires. By the end of the story, I wanted to beat her over the head with the book.
Meyer did a good job at keeping me guessing about the final conflict. She focused (maybe a little too much) on Edward and Isabella’s relationship. There were many routes she could have gone that would have made this story an old cliche, instead, she took a totally new perspective. It’s refreshing to read about vampires in a new way. Mayer introduced a sneak peek into an eccentric vampire clan that loved to play baseball.
I would have to say this was a good book. I was mostly hooked after the second half, although still disgusted with the frilly romantics that would have high school girls swooning. I don’t know what planet they’re from, but a vampire version of a Ken doll isn’t that fascinating. I was also unsatisfied with the ending. It seemed too juvenile and overly sweet. Edward and Isabella had gone through so much, just to end up at… prom? Despite all these ridiculous idiosyncrasies, I’m looking forward to reading the next two in the trilogy, as well as seeing the movie. I’ve researched it and the cast looks pretty good!
Linda Belle stirs up trouble in Sherwood Forest, hangs out with Adrian Monk solving crimes, and may or may not be the half-sister of George Michael Blueth. She's an avid reader and a compulsive writer. In her spare time she organizes her novels and sneers at Stephanie Meyers.






5 Comments so far
Leave a comment
Woo, I just finished Eclipse. I must say, you’re in for a much more interesting next two books.
And they’re making a movie?
Wait, why am I suprised? In front of TGC there were ads for The Spiderwick Chronicles, Caspian, Inkheart, and Horton Hears a Who…all book adaptations, all fantasy, except for the last one which is just…weird. And then there’s the Golden Compass itself, and The Dark is Rising came out in October. Why is fantasy adaptations suddenly a big thing? Peter Jackson, perhaps? But if you’re going to make adaptions, people, make them *right*, okay? or else just don’t bother. Leave them to me. I’ll do it right.
…
By Anne on 12.17.07 6:00 pm | Permalink
@ Anne
Haha, I think we both share that horrible dread that there will be no books we enjoy to make into film!!!
I really did like this book! I can’t wait to read the next one. The movie looks kick ass. The guy who plays Cedric Diggory is playing Edward. I must admit, I really did picture Edward looking just like the Cedric Diggory actor. (I’m to lazy to look up his real name.) Wiki Twilight and you can see more details about the movie.
I’ve actually been thinking about why there are so many fantasy films lately. I don’t think Peter Jackson as much to do with it (though I did notice some striking “copy catting” in the Golden Compass [YES I SAW IT! I LOVED IT!]). I don’t know if you know or not, but I’m not a big fan of Jackson’s. I think that since Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone producers see that these children fantasy movies are bringing in tons of revenue, especially if the story has sequels.
By Linda Belle on 12.17.07 10:29 pm | Permalink
I read this over Thanksgiving break-
I don’t have to tell you what I thought because, clearly, we share a brain.
By PJ on 12.18.07 12:08 am | Permalink
Must….read….book….
By Mommy on 12.21.07 12:24 am | Permalink
My friends are obsessed with this book, but I still haven’t gotten around to reading it.
By Chiya on 01.13.08 11:57 am | Permalink
Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>